New Cingular Wireless PCS v. Sussex County Board of Adjustment

New Cingular Wireless PCS (now known as “AT&T”) filed an application with the Sussex County Board of Adjustment (“the Board”) for a special use exception to construct a 100-foot telecommunications cell tower on a commercially zoned property located just outside of Bethany Beach. A special use exception was required before a cell tower may be erected within 500 feet of a residential zone. The Sea Pines Village Condominium Association of Owners, along with individual residents who lived near the proposed location opposed the application. The Board ultimately denied AT&T’s application. On appeal to the Superior Court, the court acknowledged in its opinion that while this appeal was pending “Bethany voted unanimously to reject AT&T’s request to use [Bethany's] water tower as an antenna location” and that “Bethany was in fact unwilling to negotiate with AT&T.” The trial court did not explain its reasoning for refusing to allow a collocation on the Bethany water tower. The Superior Court affirmed based on the record presented. In its written decision denying AT&T’s application, the Board concluded that AT&T “had not met its burden [under the Sussex County Code] of proving that the proposed use would not affect adversely the uses of adjacent and neighboring properties.” The Superior Court explained AT&T’s burden with similar language. But the Sussex County Code required a lesser burden, “special use exceptions shall be granted unless the Board finds such exceptions will not substantially affect adversely the uses of adjacent and neighboring property.” AT&T argued that the Board’s decision should have been reversed because the Board failed to apply the correct legal standard. Upon review, the Supreme Court agreed, and remanded the case for further proceedings.

New Cingular Wireless PCS v. Sussex County Board of Adjustment