Sons of Confederate Veterans v. City of Lexington, VA

SCV filed suit against the City and its officials alleging that Lexington City Code section 420-205(C) (the “Ordinance), which bans any private access to City-owned flag standards, contravenes the SCV’s First Amendment rights and breached a consent decree resolving an earlier lawsuit between SCV and the City. The court concluded there was no legal support for requiring the City to relinquish its control over the flag standards because they are not a traditional public forum; inasmuch as the Ordinance was lawfully enacted to close a designated public forum, the court affirmed the dismissal of the SCV’s free speech claim; in regards to the civil contempt claim relating to the Consent Decree, the court agreed with the district court’s conclusion that, because there was no constitutional violation posed by the Ordinance, there could be no violation of the Decree; and, because the flag standards are no longer given over to private expression, their use is not governed by the Decree. Accordingly, the court affirmed the judgment of the district court.

Sons of Confederate Veterans v. City of Lexington, VA